The real estate process in NYC is often confusing for first-time buyers, particularly when it comes to co-op ownership. Co-ops make up a majority of the city’s housing stock, but they are a unique form of ownership and have specific rules that differ from condos. One of those differences is the proprietary lease, a document that is given to shareholders at closing in place of a deed and which regulates their relationship with the cooperative building they live in. Proprietary leases are critical in understanding the nuances of co-op living. This article is meant to help prospective buyers and current residents better understand the proprietary lease and its impact on their ownership.
Unlike a rental, which is governed by NYC’s rent regulation laws, a co-op apartment owner is not considered to be a statutory tenant. Instead, they are a shareholder with ownership in the cooperative corporation, which is the entity that actually owns the building. The ownership is not a freehold interest in the property, but rather, a right to occupy a particular unit as long as they follow the provisions of the proprietary lease and New York State business law pertaining to corporations. It is the proprietary lease that lays out these provisions in detail, ensuring that shareholders are clear about their rights and responsibilities.
As such, the proprietary lease clarifies how and when maintenance charges are payable (typically on the 1st day of each month) and confirms that each shareholder is responsible for their pro rata share of any special assessments. The proprietary lease also typically includes details about the house rules and explains that a breach of those rules, whether committed by the shareholder, their family members, guests, or contractors, constitutes a default under the lease and may result in their being evicted from their unit. Understanding the proprietary lease is vital to avoiding such defaults and maintaining a good standing in the cooperative.
Another important provision of the proprietary lease is that the owner must get permission from the board to sell their shares or transfer them to a third party. The board reserves the right to approve or disapprove any sale for reasons that they deem reasonable, and the sale must occur within a certain timeframe. The proprietary lease will also detail the restrictions that are imposed on subletting, renovations, and other similar activities in the building. Grasping the nuances of the proprietary lease can help shareholders navigate these restrictions more effectively.
Finally, the proprietary lease will also include a statement that any changes to the original proprietary lease must be made by a majority vote of the members eligible to vote on such matters at a duly noticed meeting. This is important, because a change to the proprietary lease could be interpreted as a transfer of ownership and require that the shareholder pay applicable NYS and NYC transfer taxes. This is why the co-op board will never extend a proprietary lease hundreds or even thousands of years into the future, which would be considered an attempted transfer and trigger the applicable transfer tax. In fact, most co-ops will only extend a proprietary lease 30 or 40 years at most in order to avoid this problem. Having a clear understanding of the proprietary lease can help shareholders navigate these complex tax implications.
When a co-op buyer purchases an apartment, they don’t actually own the property (like a condominium owner does) but rather purchase shares in a cooperative corporation that owns the building. The proprietary lease stakes out the specifics of the relationship between the shareholder and the corporation, providing the legal foundation for their residency terms in the apartment. It also details the requirements shareholders must follow for renovations, subletting, maintenance, and repairs, among other aspects of apartment living.
The proprietary lease is one of the most crucial documents a prospective New York City homeowner should review, alongside the building’s offering plan and financial statements, when considering purchasing a coop. Understanding the proprietary lease is essential as it lays down the groundwork of the shareholder's rights and responsibilities. In fact, it’s often one of the many documents buyers will have their real estate attorney examine during their due diligence for a purchase.
While a condominium’s declaration and by-laws and amendments are recorded in the county clerk’s office, a coop’s governing documents and the proprietary lease are kept at the corporation’s main office. The major policies and rights for a shareholder are outlined in these documents and the laws of New York State pertaining to cooperative corporations. The proprietary lease plays a pivotal role in outlining these shareholder rights and the corporation’s policies.
For instance, a co-op can kick you out and repossess your apartment if you’re in bankruptcy, if you fail to pay the maintenance fees and charges, or if you violate a house rule. Additionally, the proprietary lease typically allows a co-op to break into your apartment without your permission (at your expense) if it becomes uninhabitable or if you don’t share a key with the building’s staff. This clause is an integral part of the proprietary lease, highlighting its significance in co-op living.
The proprietary lease will also contain a section on termination and the conditions under which the co-op can terminate your proprietary lease. This is a critical part of the document that every prospective coop purchaser should read and understand because it can have significant consequences. Understanding the termination clauses within the proprietary lease can prevent future misunderstandings.
There are a number of other important provisions in a proprietary lease that should be understood by anyone planning on buying a coop, including the terms of payment and whether or not you can have pets. Most importantly, a proprietary lease should specify what utilities are included in your monthly maintenance fee. Grasping the financial aspects outlined in the proprietary lease is crucial for a potential buyer.
Lastly, the proprietary lease will outline how long your apartment’s term is. For buyers who plan to finance their purchase with a mortgage, this is an extremely important document to review because a proprietary lease that ends in less than 30 years will cause problems with banks that require the borrower to pay transfer taxes. Therefore, the term length in the proprietary lease is a significant factor for potential buyers relying on financing.
When a shareholder purchases an apartment in a co-op, they acquire ownership of a share in the corporation that owns their building. However, unlike a rental property where the landlord is responsible for maintaining and repairing an individual apartment, the owner of a cooperative shares responsibilities with the board in their relationship to their home. This relationship is defined through the proprietary lease, which details the terms of occupancy for a particular apartment, and stakes out responsibilities and obligations that each shareholder must follow.
In addition to outlining the responsibilities and obligations of the shareholder, the proprietary lease will typically specify if an individual can sublet their apartment, and will also detail what happens to the property should a shareholder violate any of its terms. These provisions are crucial in maintaining the integrity of the co-op community. If a tenant violates the terms of the proprietary lease, it could result in having to move or even being evicted, showcasing the importance of adhering to the proprietary lease.
The proprietary lease will also delineate the building’s rules and regulations regarding alterations to the unit. To ensure that changes are in line with the co-op’s standards, if the shareholder wishes to make modifications to the apartment, they must first obtain approval from the board of directors, illustrating another key aspect of the proprietary lease. For example, a contractor may be required to provide a written cost estimate for all work before the owner can receive approval. A co-op board is also likely to have strict requirements about who can live in the apartment.
These rules can be complex and vary significantly from one building to another, which can often affect a buyer’s ability to purchase a co-op. With respect to the proprietary lease, it is vital for buyers to understand these complexities before making a purchase. For instance, some co-ops have window policies that require an incoming buyer to remediate windows, adding to the overall cost of purchasing an apartment.
A proprietary lease not only outlines the rules and regulations but can also set forth the length of time that a shareholder is allowed to occupy the apartment. Typically, this will be medium to long-term, and the proprietary lease plays a vital role in determining these timeframes. In some instances, a co-op may extend its land lease before it expires to allow for an extended lease term, affecting the shareholder’s proprietary lease. This can be important for a buyer, as it can help with obtaining financing from lenders.
It is also crucial to understand that a co-op’s land lease can be terminated by the board of directors if the tenant fails to pay maintenance fees or violates any other terms of the agreement, underscoring the importance of adhering to the proprietary lease. This potential for termination can be a significant threat to tenants that own an apartment in a co-op and is another reason why it is vital for buyers to thoroughly review the proprietary lease before purchasing.
Lastly, amendments to the proprietary lease can occur through an affirmative vote, affecting all shareholders. A knowledgeable attorney can provide additional guidance on understanding the proprietary lease and ensuring that potential buyers are aware of their responsibilities when owning a co-op apartment in NYC.
Avenue Law Firm
99 Park Ave 10th Floor, New York, NY 10016, United States
(212) 729-4090